A renovation loan has a feature no ordinary mortgage has: it's based on what the house will be worth after the work is done. The appraiser values a finished house that exists only on paper. In Philadelphia, where values can change from one block to the next, this is the step that decides how big your renovation can be.
What the appraiser is valuing
The appraiser gets your contract, the scope of work and the contractor's budget. They estimate the as-completed value: the market value of this house with every item on that scope finished.
That number drives the loan:
- On an FHA 203k, the loan is limited by the as-improved value and the FHA limit, which is $630,200 for a one-unit home in the Philadelphia area in 2026.
- On a HomeStyle, the renovation can be up to 75% of the lesser of the purchase price plus renovation, or the as-completed value.
If the value comes in low, the budget has to shrink, or you bring more cash.
Comparables, block by block
The appraiser supports the as-completed value with comparable sales: recent sales of similar houses, ideally renovated to a similar standard, and close by.
That's easier in some Philadelphia neighborhoods than others:
- Fishtown, Graduate Hospital, Point Breeze, East Passyunk. Plenty of renovated rowhome sales. Comps are usually easy to find, and a strong renovation is supported.
- Transitional blocks. A renovated house may be ahead of its block. The appraiser may have to reach farther for comps, or give more weight to unrenovated sales.
- Collar-county twins and singles in Upper Darby, Norristown or Bensalem. Comparables follow the housing type, and the township often matters more than the specific street.
How to keep the budget in line with the value
Renovate for the block, not your Pinterest board. A $70,000 kitchen in a neighborhood where renovated houses sell for $260,000 won't be fully reflected in the value.
Put the value-adding items first. Systems, roof, kitchen, baths and layout support value. Some specialty finishes don't.
Give the appraiser a precise scope. "Renovate kitchen" invites a conservative value. A scope listing the cabinets, counters and appliances lets the appraiser match it to renovated comps.
Look at sold prices, not list prices. Before you set the budget, look at what renovated houses on nearby blocks actually sold for.
When the appraisal comes in low
It happens. The options:
- Trim the scope. Move lower-value items out of the loan and do them later.
- Renegotiate the purchase price. A low as-completed value is useful evidence when you go back to the seller.
- Bring more cash to cover the gap.
- Switch programs. If the issue is FHA's limit rather than the value, HomeStyle's higher conforming limit ($832,750 in 2026) may fix it.
A consultant's feasibility visit and an honest look at comps before the appraisal make the low-value surprise much less likely. Our rowhome budget guide helps you size the work before you commit.
The short version
- Renovation loans are based on the as-completed value of the house, as if the work were done.
- Appraisers support that value with renovated comparable sales, and in Philadelphia comps can change block to block.
- Size the renovation to the block, and give the appraiser a specific scope.
- If the value comes in low, you can trim scope, renegotiate, add cash or switch programs.
Size it before you sign
Send us the address and your plans. We'll look at recent renovated sales nearby and tell you whether the budget fits the value.
Get Pre-Qualified Free · Free consultation
Jeff Onofrio, SVP of Renovation Lending, NMLS #38670 · HMA Mortgage, NMLS #139164 · Equal Housing Lender. Not a commitment to lend. Appraised values are determined by independent appraisers.